Best Ice Fishing Boots of 2021: Complete Reviews With Comparisons

By James James | Fishing Gear Reviews

best ice fishing boots
Spread the love

Some people dread the winter, but the same can’t be said of your average ice fisher.

Ice fishers can’t wait for the temperature to drop below freezing and for the ice to be thick enough to walk out on.

But to properly enjoy ice fishing, whether you’re hunting walleye or crappies, you need to dress appropriately for the weather.

If you’re not wearing the right boots, then a lot of heat can be lost through your feet.

So, today we’ll help you find the best ice fishing boots by reviewing five highly-rated options.

Comparison Chart

Muck Boot mens Woody Arctic Ice Work Boot, Bark Mobuc Mini, 13 US

BUY ON AMAZON

Grundens DECK-BOSS Boot | Durable, Waterproof, Grey, M 8

BUY ON AMAZON

Kamik Men’s Icebreaker Work Boot, Black, 10 M US

BUY ON AMAZON

Columbia Women’s Ice Maiden Ii Snow Boot, Cordovan, Siberia, 10 B US

BUY ON AMAZON

NORTIV 8 Men’s Waterproof Hiking Winter Snow Boots Insulated Fur Liner Lightweight Outdoor Booties Black Size 11 M US MOUNTAINEER-1M

BUY ON AMAZON

Best Ice Fishing Boots: A Review

1. Muck Boots Arctic Ice Extreme Conditions Boots

The Original Muck Boot Company specializes in providing 100% waterproof boots and shoes that are protective, reliable, and comfortable.

Their Extreme Conditions boots feature the most advanced outer soles for trekking on wet ice and offer incredible support and warmth.

Product Highlights

These boots are the most expensive we’ve featured on this list, but if you have the money to invest, they’re nothing short of perfect ice fishing boots.

  • Material Used

These boots are made from 8mm-thick neoprene, which provides warmth and waterproofing throughout the entire boot, from top to bottom.

Neoprene is the material primarily used for manufacturing wetsuits as it’s known for its heat-retaining properties.

The flexibility of this material also adjusts to the shape of your foot, preventing chafing and blisters from forming.

  • Superior Grip

The advanced “Vibram” soles take their name from the Italian word for “tank tread”, providing the ultimate grip on slippery surfaces.

In fact, this sole was designed with wet ice in mind and represents a brand new approach to walking on slippery ice without the need for metal.

  • Sizing

The boots also have a soft fleece lining and 2mm thermal foam under the footbed to enhance comfort and warmth.

They are comfort rated from a numbing negative 60 degrees Fahrenheit up to 30 degrees.

We also noticed that these boots are sized really well, from a size seven to a size 15.

You don’t need to go up a size to account for extra thick socks as the company has already made this adjustment for you.

The extra roominess is also great for people who usually wear wide sizes.

The Good

We were particularly impressed with the Vibram outer soles on these boots.

You can enjoy superior grip on wet ice without the need to buy separate ice cleats to fit over your boots.

We also love the fact that these boots keep your feet really warm and dry all day, meaning you can be out ice fishing all day!

The Bad

The only negative thing we can find to say about these boots is that they are quite expensive.

They are over double the cost of some of the other boots on this list, so they won’t be affordable for everyone.

PROS

  • True to size
  • 100% waterproof
  • Provide advanced grip on wet ice
  • Comfortable and flexible materials
  • Will keep your feet warm all-day

CONS

  • Not affordable for everyone

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

2. Grundens DECK-BOSS Boots

Grundens have been supplying gear to fishers for over 100 years, so it’s no wonder they’re highly regarded by both sport and commercial fishers.

These DECK-BOSS boots are part of an entire collection designed to provide comfort to fishers out on the water all day long.

Product Highlights

Let’s take a look at some of the innovative features that help these boots protect you from the elements.

  • Durability

One thing we can say about these boots is that they are incredibly durable and long-lasting, making them a great investment.

When exposed to severe weather conditions, many materials can be prone to fracturing under stress.

However, these boots have a flexible toe cap with injection-molded uppers that completely eliminates the potential for cracking and delamination.

  • Grip and Waterproofing

Thanks to their patented rubber outsole, the ” Herkules Grip”, the boots provide excellent grip on slippery and wet surfaces.

This outsole is compression molded and certified with SRC Slip Resistance, which is the highest level of slip-resistant certification.

The boots are 100% waterproof, and the 15-inch flexible upper folds down with a silicone band to help protect your pants and legs from getting wet.

  • Lifetime Warranty

One of the other great things about these boots is that they come with a lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects.

The warranty includes defects in the materials, as well as the workmanship.

This means you can be confident that these boots make a lifetime investment, seeing you through many years of ice fishing ahead.

The Good

We think the highlight of these DECK-BOSS boots is the lifetime warranty provided by the company.

The boots are incredibly tough and durable, but if something does go wrong with them, then you can get them fixed or replaced free of charge.

The Bad

These boots are a little on the heavy side, so your legs and feet may feel more tired when wearing them all day fishing.

They’re also not insulated, so you may have to buy a size up and team them with insulated socks to keep your feet warm out on the ice.

PROS

  • Durable
  • 100% waterproof
  • Superior grip
  • Risk-free purchase

CONS

  • Heavy to wear all-day
  • Not insulated

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

3. Kamin Men’s Icebreaker Work Boots

Kamin is a family-owned and operated company based in Canada, bringing over 120 years of experience and expertise to the footwear industry.

Their Icebreaker work boots feature a removable inner liner, offering you a versatile boot that you can wear for multiple types of fishing.

Product Highlights

These boots are more affordable than the previous two we featured yet still possess many desirable features, some of which we’ve highlighted below.

  • Waterproofing

Like the previous two pairs of boots we’ve featured, these boots are also 100% waterproof.

They are made from lightweight synthetic rubber and also feature adjustable nylon collars to keep the water out of the top of the boot.

  • Warm Removable Liner

These boots feature an 8mm thick Zylex removable liner that helps keep your feet really warm when you’re wearing them.

Zylex liners claim to be comfortable in temperatures as low as -40 degrees Fahrenheit.

They are designed to wick moisture away from your foot, trap warm air, and reflect body heat back to the foot.

The polyester material has a cushion and molds around the shape of your feet, making the boots really comfortable to wear all day.

The fact that the insulated liner on this boot is removable makes them versatile for everyday outdoor wear.

It also means you can replace it from time to time, keeping the insides of your boots as good as new.

  • Durability and Slip-Resistance

These boots are durably made to ensure they last you for many ice fishing seasons ahead.

They also feature TRACKER outsoles with deep lugs embedded in them to help provide stability on slippery terrains.

The Good

We love the removable liners these boots come with.

They’re warm, comfortable, and by being removable, they offer these boots an element of versatility not seen in many boots like this.

The Bad

Unfortunately, while the boots are very warm, we’re not sure they’ll keep your feet warm if you’re out all day on the ice.

Some people have also had problems with the upper material cracking and then letting water in.

PROS

  • Comfortable
  • 100% waterproof
  • Removable liner lends versatile use

CONS

  • Prone to cracking
  • Don’t keep your feet quite as warm as advertised

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

4. Columbia Women’s Ice Maiden Snow Boots

Columbia has been creating innovative outdoor gear since 1938, and the company is passionate about the outdoors.

Their Ice Maiden boots offer a mixture of style and insulated protection for women who enjoy being out on the ice.

Product Highlights

Let’s take a quick look at some of the highlights of Columbia’s Ice Maiden boots that make them some of the best ice fishing boots for women.

  • Waterproof and Warm

These boots are made from a mixture of waterproof leather and textile, making them a great option for ice fishing or cold, wet weather in general.

Being a lace-up design, you need to make sure you lace them up properly to ensure you’ll stay dry when submerging your foot into the water.

They also feature 200-gram insulation, which will help keep you warm during the coldest days of fishing.

Plus, the Omni-Grip advanced traction rubber soles will help you keep your footing when you’re out fishing on wet ice.

  • Comfortable and Streamlined

These boots also feature Techlite, lightweight midsoles with superior cushioning for long-lasting comfort.

Many winter boots, especially those suitable for wearing on ice, are heavy and bulky.

That said, these boots are surprisingly streamlined in design, and their lace-up closure provides an adjustable and secure fit.

We think these boots will be very popular with women since they don’t look particularly clunky or bottom-heavy.

The Good

We love the way these boots look, and we also like the lace-up design as it enables you to get a really good fit.

The Bad

The grip and traction that these boots offer, especially on wet ice, aren’t as good as others on this list.

So, you may need to team them with some ice cleats for wet ice days.

PROS

  • Stylish, streamlined design
  • Waterproof
  • Keep your feet warm
  • Comfortable and supportive

CONS

  • Grip isn’t the best

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

5. Nortiv 8 Men’s Winter Snow Boots

Nortiv 8 manufactures a wide range of outdoor boots and shoes suitable for various terrains and weather conditions.

These boots offer fishers who want to keep their feet as dry and comfortable as possible while ice fishing on a budget.

Product Highlights

These boots might be some of the most affordable on this list, but they still feature all of the desirable qualities needed by ice fishers.

  • Waterproofing

These boots are constructed with a genuine fabric upper to offer fantastic water and wind resistance against freezing weather.

They also have a seam-sealed, waterproof TPR outsole that wraps around your entire foot in the shape of a shoe.

That means your feet stay completely dry, even if you have to step in a few inches of water to get to the ice.

  • Warmth and Coziness

These boots feature a three-fold warming system for your feet, making them cozy to wear.

This includes a removable, faux fur insole, which also offers support and comfort.

Plus, a 200-gram high-quality insulated lining keeps your feet warm down to -25 degrees Fahrenheit.

  • Non-Slip and Other Safety Features

The outsole of these boots is non-slip and flexible to a variety of outdoor terrains.

Plus, these boots have a protective toe cap and reflective, decorative lines on them to increase your safety at night.

These boots are also easier to pull on and off than many others since they have a wider boot opening and drawstrings for you to grab onto.

The Good

This will be a great pair of boots for you to invest in if you’re shopping on a budget, as they tick a lot of boxes without breaking the bank.

The Bad

Unfortunately, these boots are only recommended for temperatures as low as -25 degrees Fahrenheit.

PROS

  • Affordable
  • Insulated
  • Help keep you safer at night
  • Easy to pull on and off

CONS

  • Won’t be warm enough for a full day of ice fishing
  • The grip isn’t as good as the other options

CHECK LATEST PRICE ON AMAZON.COM

Ice Fishing Boots Buyer’s Guide

Although we’ve reviewed certain ice fishing boots, you need to learn about the most critical features to consider when choosing a pair of ice fishing boots.

Insulation

Being out in the frigid weather requires you to wear something that will keep you warm.

Boots with enough insulation ensure your feet stay protected and warm.

Waterproofing

Apart from ensuring you stay warm, you must also make sure your feet are protected from water and ice.

Waterproof ice fishing boots are your best option. If you opt for water-resistant models, they won’t completely prevent the water from seeping through the boots.

Material Used

When searching for a pair of boots for ice fishing, you must check the materials used in constructing the exterior and interior.

It’s always best to go for boots with an exterior made of heavy-duty materials and interior made of soft material.

This way, your boots provide both protection and comfort while you’re out fishing.

Also, choose boots with a great level of traction for safety since ice is slippery.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. What Boots Do You Wear in the Snow?

When you’re buying a new pair of snow boots, the first thing you’ll want to do is make sure they’re waterproof enough for your needs.

Some regions experience more snow than others, so consider how high up your leg you need the waterproofing to go.

You also want them to have a good grip, so you don’t go sliding around on icy patches.

Finally, a nice cozy lining will help keep your feet warm, even while surrounded by snow.

2. What Shoes Should I Wear for Ice Fishing?

When you go ice fishing, you should wear boots specially made for snowy or icy conditions.

This will ensure you have a good grip while walking out onto the ice, and you’ll also massively benefit from the waterproof features they usually possess.

The top layer of the ice can get really slushy, and it’s important to keep your feet dry if you want to be warm and comfortable out there.

3. What Type of Ice Is Safe To Walk On?

The strongest type of ice is clear blue or black, as it’s made when the lake water is freezing.

When you’re talking about clear ice, usually around four inches thick is safe to walk on.

4. How Many Layers Should I Wear Ice Fishing?

The number of layers you wear is really quite personal because it depends on how cold you feel and how thick your layers are.

Ideally, you’ll want to wear enough layers to keep you warm while out in the, often below freezing, elements.

Then be able to take them off one by one as you start to warm up, either from exertion, the heat of the sun, or when you’re inside your ice shack.

5. Are Muck Boots Good for Ice Fishing?

Muck Boots are highly recommended for ice fishing since their products are always 100% waterproof and reliable.

They also utilize advanced arctic grip technology for the outer soles of their snow boots, making walking on ice easier without slipping.

What Are the Best Ice Fishing Boots?

Without a doubt, the best ice fishing boots, in our opinion, are the Muck Boots.

With their Arctic ice grip technology and warm, waterproof construction, you really can’t go wrong, and this will make a solid, long-term investment.

However, if you just like to fish for an hour or so and don’t have much money to spend, then the boots from Nortiv 8 come a close second.

About the Author

Leave a Comment:

Leave a Comment: