If you are new to fishing, it is only normal to wonder which is the better reel to start your practice with—baitcaster vs spinning reel? What are their main differences? Which offer better results? Both the spinning reel and the baitcaster utilizes the same basic design. However, both choices also come with their individual advantages and drawbacks.
With that said, should you start out with the easier-to-use spinning reel, or should you jump right into using a baitcaster to reel in the big ones? Of course, this will depend on your skill level and what kind of fishing you’re planning to do.
Below, we would compare these two types of fishing reels in detail in hopes to help you decide which is the better option for you. By the end of this article, you’d have enough knowledge to make an informed decision and be one step closer to becoming the kind of angler that you wishes to be!
For newcomers to the sport, especially those new to freshwater angling, starting out with a spinning reel is the better choice. The spinning outfit of a spinning reel is easy to operate and fairly pain-free to maintain. It uses a lighter line, is easy to cast, and is ideal for fishing for freshwater fish.
On the other hand, a baitcaster is a little more difficult to operate. It is used more by professional anglers because it can be cast with pinpoint accuracy, and it uses a heavier line to catch bigger fish. However, there is a dialed-in drag resistance, and it requires a higher skill set to thumb the spool as the line flows off. If you cannot find that sweet spot of thumb pressure, you will experience a backlash of tangled line.
To give you a better idea as to how these two differ, below is a detailed list of their specs.
To figure out which of these two reels is better suited for you, we’ll be comparing them head-to-head in eight categories. Each category will answer the following questions:
Most fishermen will tell you that your gear should be specified toward the fish you are planning to catch. This is not only to increase your chances of catching fish but also to make it easier for you to handle your gear.
When it comes to the kinds of fish you want to catch, which should you use: a baitcaster or a spinning reel?
Spinning reels are best for small- to medium-sized fish. This means that, with a spinning reel, you can catch any kind of fish from tiny bluegill to medium-sized bass.
Baitcasters are best to catch large-sized fish breeds. Many anglers will tell you to use a baitcaster when fishing for predator fish, such as muskellunge (musky). Also, this kind of reel is good for catching monster catfish and large bass.
The next thing to consider is what weight line you will be using. You should also think about what lure size you plan to use. These will determine the kind of fishing reel that you need.
If you are planning on using a 10-pound line, a spinning reel is the better choice. This weight of line provides the necessary flexibility and bendiness that you will need not to break the line while reeling in a fish. Also, live baits and lightweight lures work well with spinning reels.
For heavier lines and lures, a baitcaster reel is better as it offers a higher level of control and accuracy while casting compared to a spinning reel.
Obviously, you must also consider your skill level when choosing the right reel. How much time do you want to spend figuring out how to use your gear?
If you are new to fishing, you don’t want to spend too much time figuring out your gear, especially if you want to dive right in. The spinning reel is easier to use, and the line doesn’t tangle as easily. In fact, many experienced fishermen still choose to use a spinning reel for the convenience it offers.
If you want to try out advanced fishing, the time spent on learning how to master a baitcaster will be well worth it. A baitcaster is ideal for advanced fishing skill levels if you do already have some experience. Just be prepared to spend the extra time on learning how to cast and dealing with possible line tangles.
Accuracy will depend on where you are fishing, what kind of fish you are fishing for, and how you are fishing. Then again, accuracy may not be as important for beginners as it is to an experienced angler.
Spinning reels do not provide a high level of accuracy. They are ideal for lake fishing when you don’t really mind where the bait lands.
Baitcasters allow for the highest levels of accuracy. They enable you to aim for a particular spot and hit it with precision every single time. Moreover, if you make a bad cast, you can quickly stop the cast to avoid other issues.
A baitcaster’s accuracy is perfect for kayak and boat fishing, or pond fishing where you aim around lily pads or foliage.
Maintenance is essential if you want to maximize the durability of your fishing equipment. Maintenance is the basic care for your reels, and the good news is that both require around the same level of maintenance.
Basically, it all comes down to disassembling the reels and cleaning the components with an appropriate solution. Then, you grease the gear teeth, oil the bearing, and reassemble everything.
When it comes to maintenance, spinning reels demand less time because they have a simpler reel design.
Baitcasters have a more complex structure, so it will take more time to go through the process of maintaining one. Maintaining it is not more difficult, per se, but it will take more time.
Each reel does have a variable shelf life. Still, you have to remember that durability also depends on the maintenance of the reels and what occurs on each trip.
Spinning reels can have a shorter shelf life than their counterparts. This is because they have a less intricate construction, are less sturdy, and might have less durability. However, with proper maintenance, a spinning reel can also last for years.
If you are looking for a reel with a longer shelf life, one you can use a greater number of times, you need a baitcaster. With a more complex construction, they are sturdier and more durable than a spinning reel. Keep in mind, however, that though baitcasters should handle large fish well, one can still break.
Nothing can ruin your fishing trip more than a tangled or jammed reel. The hours spent untangling your line could be hours fishing spent fishing, which is why you need to choose the right reel.
It’s important to keep in mind that experienced fishermen understand that tangles and jams are a part of fishing, and they have experience with minimizing the chances of tangling.
Spinning reels are tangle- and jam-resistant. If you are a beginner angler, you might want to choose this kind of reel so that you can spend more time fishing, rather than untangling your line.
Once you master the process of preventing tangles and jams, as well as untangling lines faster, you can move on to a baitcaster. This type of reel is more prone to tangles and jams.
Line capacity, casting distance, and gear ratios are other things that you might want to take into consideration when choosing the best reel.
Spinning reels have a lesser line capacity than baitcasters. They are easier to cast and can reach their maximum range, though their maximum casting range is less than a baitcaster. Lastly, spinning reels have a lesser range of ratios available.
Baitcasters tend to have a larger line capacity than spinning reels. Because of the larger line capacity, they have a longer casting distance. Furthermore, baitcasters have a greater range of ratios available.
Comparing the spinning reel to the baitcaster tells us that a spinning reel is more suitable for beginners while the baitcaster is better suited for more experienced and professional anglers. However, it depends on what kind of fishing you are planning to do.
If you need more accuracy, such as with kayak fishing in heavy foliage, you might want to use a baitcaster for its higher level of casting accuracy.
Now, let’s go over a few of the immediately noticeable pros and cons of both reels. In knowing this, you can better decide which of the two is more suited for your needs and skill level.
When it all comes down to choosing between baitcaster vs spinning reel, which do you think is the better choice? It is almost impossible to pronounce a winner because they both have their own unique features and drawbacks. Moreover, if you become a serious fisherman, you will probably end up using both at some point.
As a beginner or someone who wants to take their family on a hassle-free fishing trip, we suggest going with a spinning reel. It is easy to use and is less prone to tangling and jamming. Additionally, it’s suitable for everyday lake, pond, or river fishing and for catching average-sized fish.
On the other hand, if you want to invest effort and time into learning your craft and bettering your fishing skills, we recommend using a baitcaster. A baitcaster gives you an impressive amount of control when casting. Plus, the reels are sturdier and more durable. If you want to catch big fish or predators, such as monster catfish or musky, you will need a baitcaster.
The most important advice we can offer is to be sure to contemplate your fishing plans and expectations. What kind of fish do you expect to catch? What kind of bait will you use? Live? Lures? How heavy? Will you be on a boat? Will you need to maneuver your casting around foliage? After considering your plans, choose your fishing reels and the rest of your equipment accordingly. This is the best way to maximize your results and your overall fishing experience.